We went in the off-season, in December, and paid about 1/4 the summer rate, which was great. Not much to do at Waterton then, however., and clouds spoiled the views of the mountains. We had steak at the restaurant and it was superb, and the brussel sprouts were to die for. Wait staff was excellent, however, the front desk asked us to make a reservation even though there were only three couples dining there that night, including us. Part of the charm, I guess. When we ate breakfast, there were deer grazing just outside the restaurant window, along the shoreline. The room was excellent and comfortable, and the bathroom was huge, as was the shower. It was awesome to stay at an essentially brand new hotel at a national park. You don't encounter that every day.

The weather didn't cooperate. There was nothing the hotel could do about that. We could never afford the normal summer rate, which is unfortunate.

The location of the hotel was THE BEST! It was totally rebuilt after the 2017 fire so all materials within the hotel/room and the exterior of the hotel are in excellent shape. Our upstairs, KING room was decorated in the MISSION style - the large bathroom shower has large 24x48 porcelain marble-look tiles enclosed with a large, clear, glass door. The king bed was VERY comfortable. We also loved the touch of having a very comfortable mission chair we could turn toward our long window to just sit and view the lake and Prince of Wales Hotel in the distance. Our whole room/including the bathroom was incredibly clean. Our meal in the Kilmorey restaurant was sublime. I had the French Onion Soup which was amazing along with a delicious small caesar salad. On warm days you can eat outdoors at their restaurant and take in the views that are as beautiful as anywhere in the world. We were within walking distance of the whole town. Please note the Kilmorey is OPEN ALL YEAR long, so you can experience it at any time of year. The staff in both the hotel and restaurant were very friendly and accomodating.

Everything was great. Really nice rooms, Nice finish, great view. The buffet style breakfast they had while we were there was the best breakfast I have ever had. It was all delicious. The chief and the team were fantastic, same with the servers as well!.

The only this was thinner walls but that is not unique to their property and I never really had any issue with it.

Very high end hotel. Location and cleanliness were excellent. Beautifully presented hotel (we heard it was rebuilt from fire in 2022, so it’s basically brand new and it shows). Pub was good, restaurant was excellent, waking distance from everything, the only thing we’ll think twice about in future is the price.

My only complaint is the price. Website said $350/night which was already really high, but after taxes, etc it worked out to $410/night which was monstrously expensive for essentially a big bedroom and bathroom. I get National Parks are pricey and everything is more expensive now, but that is borderline outrageous. We’ll look around for a better price before staying there again.

Loved the fireplace, this place has a lot of character and loved the entire cozy look of it. Loved the back easy access to the lake it was beautiful. Also loved the orange pekoe tea in the room it was perfect!

More options for food, maybe small cafeteria option on site would be great. Everything outside was closed by 7pm even though google showed open upto 8pm but possibly due to off season. We missed having some good coffee and enjoy the lake just like Banff.

The room was so amazing! It was spotless, and the bed was so comfortable! The view was really nice, and it was sooooooo relaxing to be able to lay in bed and watch movies. They also put a tray with tea and cookies on the bed for us!

My only complaint(s) was the bathroom didn't have a fan (the fiance got really bad food poisoning), and the lobby was closed after a certain hour. We went out on a late night walk and the door latches shut and locks when you leave so you can't get back in(we tested it with one of us going out and seeing lol) The door was locked but we propped it open slowly with its own lock so we could get back in. I'm just thinking about what we would have done if we were out late drinking and couldn't get back in the building lol The price was high for the room but honestly, it was worth it, I just wish it was a bit cheaper so I could have afforded to stay 2 nights. Also I think the elevator is haunted already 😂

Beautiful location. I really liked the food and thought it was good value for the cost all things considered. Bed was ok and the room was very clean. The hotel is warm and comfortable and the view of the lake was magnificent

I couldn't find the Oilers game on the tv but it was on in the bar so good enough! It would be nice if you could lock and unlock the back door with a room key

The location is quieter since it’s farther away from the shops. Enjoyed the walking path at the back by Emerald Bay. The room was very clean and the welcome tray of tea and cookies is a very nice touch! Staff were very friendly and helpful. Our breakfast was delicious and the servers were great.

The pull out sofa bed was so uncomfortable my 15 year old could not sleep in it. It needs to be replaced.

The staff was wonderful! The food was so good!! Kudos to the new cook and his inspiration to make food from scratch and use local ingredients. I highly recommend this restaurant or pub for any town visitors. Wednesday evening happened to be Trivia night in the pub, which was a fun event. The pub and restaurant servers were such welcoming, lovely ladies!! For an off-season overnight stay, we were pleasantly surprised! I highly recommend the Kilmorey Lodge.

The staff at the front desk was very pleasant and helpful. We were missing a chair in the room and Lineal (spelling?) got us one immediately. I think he hauled it up there himself. The view from our balcony was great - well worth the extra cost of a Waterview room. Cozy robes were an extra treat. We dined at the hotel restaurant - great food an service.