7.8

332 reviews

Islander Inn

Islander Inn

225 Erie Street, Put In Bay, 43456, Ohio, United States

Choose dates to view prices

Outdoor swimming pool

Free wifi

Air conditioning

Bar

Non-smoking rooms

Wheelchair accessible

Beach chairs/Loungers

Elevator

Islander Inn

Welcome to the Islander Inn, your perfect getaway in the charming enclave of Put-in-Bay, Ohio! Just a stone's throw from the city center at 225 Erie Street, this delightful hotel offers you an escape filled with sunshine and adventure. For an unbeatable price starting from just $110 per night, you’ll find yourself basking in comfort, with cozy rooms designed for relaxation after a day of exploration.

Dive into relaxation at the hotel's outdoor swimming pool—complete with complimentary access for all guests! Whether you're sipping a cocktail from the bar, lounging on the beach chairs, or enjoying a picnic in the designated area, the Islander Inn has all the amenities to keep spirits high. With free Wi-Fi and air conditioning, you'll be connected and comfortable while enjoying the beautiful Ohio sunshine. Plus, for those planning gatherings or meetings, there are banquet facilities available for an extra charge.

The Islander Inn has received glowing reviews from travelers, showcasing its incredible hospitality and inviting atmosphere. Wheelchair accessibility and non-smoking rooms make it a welcoming destination for everyone. So why wait? Your beachside retreat at the Islander Inn, with its array of amenities and stunning location, is the perfect base for making unforgettable memories!

As you explore the vibrant surroundings of Put-in-Bay, you'll discover that the Islander Inn is not just a place to stay, but a gateway to a multitude of exciting adventures! Picture yourself strolling along pristine beaches or indulging in tantalizing local cuisine at nearby eateries. The island is renowned for its scenic views and fun-filled activities, including exhilarating boat rentals and charming wineries that you simply can't miss. Don't forget to stop by the iconic Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, just a short trip from your hotel, which offers breathtaking panoramas and a bit of history to spice up your vacation.

After a day of adventure, why not take advantage of the hotel’s seasonal outdoor pools? Dive into one, splash around with friends and family, or just unwind poolside with a good book in hand. The enchanting ambiance of the outdoor area is perfect for evening relaxation, whether you're stargazing or enjoying the company of fellow travelers. And if you're feeling social, the hotel bar serves up delightful cocktails to make any sunset even more magical. It’s the ideal spot to reminisce about your day, share stories, and plan for the adventures that await.

When it’s time to wind down, the Islander Inn provides the comfort you crave. With a variety of spacious rooms designed for your ultimate relaxation, you can sink into plush bedding after a fulfilling day. Wake up refreshed and ready to tackle another day of exploration in Put-in-Bay. Don’t forget to join the lively conversations at breakfast, where fellow guests share their favorite island experiences! This slice of Ohio paradise has everything you need for an unforgettable vacation, so book your stay today and become part of the Islander Inn family!

Closest airports

Windsor Airport

43.5mi

Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport

48.1mi

Toledo Express Airport

51.2mi

Cleveland-Hopkins International Airport

52.8mi

Burke Lakefront Airport

59.4mi

Most popular amenities

Outdoor swimming pool

Free wifi

Air conditioning

Bar

Non-smoking rooms

Wheelchair accessible

Beach chairs/Loungers

Elevator

Picnic area

Balcony

Upper floors accessible by elevator

Rooms

Quadruple Room with Balcony in Islander Inn

Show 4 photos

Quadruple Room, Balcony

2 Queen Size Beds

325 sqft

Private Bathroom

Balcony

Flat-screen TV

Air conditioning

x4

More details

King Room - Disability Access in Islander Inn

Show 4 photos

King Room, Accessible

1 King Size Bed

325 sqft

Private Bathroom

Flat-screen TV

Air conditioning

Shower

+

More details

King Room in Islander Inn

Show 4 photos

King Room

1 King Size Bed

325 sqft

Private Bathroom

Flat-screen TV

Air conditioning

Shower

+

More details

Queen Room with Two Queen Beds in Islander Inn

Show 4 photos

Room - 2 Queen

2 Queen Size Beds

325 sqft

Private Bathroom

Flat-screen TV

Air conditioning

Upper floors accessible by elevator

+

More details

Show 4 photos

Room, Balcony

Balcony

Flat-screen TV

+

More details

Standard Room

+

More details

Guest reviews

7.8

332 reviews

Categories of assessments

Cleanliness

Comfort

Location

Facilities

Staff

Value for money

WiFi quality

Featured reviews:

🇺🇸

Madison

8.2

May 2024

Property was nice and clean and in a convenient location. Mini fridge in the room. Convenient location close to other pools and bars. Short walking distance from the jet express, no golf cart rental needed (also offered by the hotel if you choose). Great communication. Half of the island lost power due to a storm and was updated on when it would likely be back on. We had a small leak in the window seal (only noticed rain water during the storm), front desk was informed, they offered to come clean the carpet and no charge taken from the security deposit. Air conditioner kept the room nice and cold. Towels and soap provided. Clean sheets and comfortable pillows. Guest names provided at check in and wrist bands put on to prevent others from entering the hotel after hours.

Tv in our room was on the smaller side. Didn’t bother us at all because we didn’t use it.

🇺🇸

Carolyn

10

July 2024

We avoided the weekend crowds by arriving Sunday evening and appreciated the quiet atmosphere during our three-day stay. It was nice to have a choice of pools to jump in, and we had fun exploring the island. The location of the Inn made it convenient to walk almost everywhere we wanted to go. Coffee was available every morning in the lobby, and we liked having a refrigerator in the room. The staff did a good job cleaning up the mayflies - those cute little pests.

We are not sure why washcloths weren't provided, but we didn't ask.

🇺🇸

Angela

8.2

September 2023

Very clean comfortable and a great location. The lady working the front desk at checkout was very nice. She helped me get a golf cart. Held our bags til we actually left the island. Answered all my questions. Three ladies that was with me had never been to the island.

I was told the pool was open until 10. We checked in at 8. Went back to our room to change ( which we told the guy when he said it was open until 10) within literally 10 minutes HE CLOSED the pool !! I went bqck to the lobby he said SORRY!! I said you knew all four of us was going to swim !! Very nice area we just didnt get to enjoy it. They didnt offer to let us swim at checkout( i told the lady working what he did !!

🇺🇸

Stacy

8.2

June 2024

It was close to all the restaurants and had nice pools to Swim in. Loved the golf carts, staff very friendly.

Being all the way at other end of property. Other guests were allowed to come and swim and hangout and drink at the hotel. Had to wait until people got drunk to let my teenagers swim. Also, there was no way to hook up ps5 for entertainment through the night. So lower tv and make extra outlets . Make it more family oriented vs party oriented.

🇺🇸

Paul

8.2

August 2023

We were in the back building. Recently renovated. Nice, bed was nice. The air conditioning didn't cool us down as much as we wanted (but our friends next door said that theirs was very cold). Pool is nice. Once we figured out the shortcuts, getting anywhere on the main part of the island was super easy.

Other than the air conditioning not being cold as much as we wanted it to be (but it did work), nothing to complain about. Oh, one other thing. I reserved/rented a golf cart for the stay. However, the cart had to be returned by 9pm each night. This is even though we got the same cart every day. I was out with my friends, but had to break away while I drove the cart back to the motel.

🇺🇸

Guajardo

10

June 2023

The staff was amazing and helpful. The security team was attentive and friendly. The location was amazing, with a very short walk to the main area on the island. I loved being able to rent a cart from the Inn rather than hoping to get one from the vendor. The front desk staff was amazing and helpful. I even used the text service for a cab number when i was stuck further away and received an answer within a timely major, which was a life saver.

The only thing that was off to me is the room we had did not have a coffee machine and a microwave which I guess I'm used to from other places I've stayed. The price for the room is high but once I met the staff and realized the location I feel the price is justified.

🇺🇸

Angela

10

August 2024

The location was perfect for walking downtown! Staff was friendly! Our room was recently updated and was perfect! Loved the walk-in shower. AC worked great and the minifridge kept our drinks cold! The lazy river pool was wonderful and relaxing! It was away from the party pool but could still enjoy the music!

Not much not to like!

🇺🇸

Conrad

10

July 2024

The location is excellent and the three pools and swim up bar added great value

The pool area closes at 9:00 pm and there isn’t anywhere on-site to relax in the event you don’t want to go for late night drinks or dinner (other than your room). It would be nice to have a place for friends to hangout after 9:00 pm on-site.

🇺🇸

Bobbi

9.1

August 2023

It was very clean and in a great location. Beds were super comfortable. Also every staff member I came in contact with was SO friendly and helpful and accommodating. Jeremy, the security guard, is an absolute gem! Give him a raise! We loved him!

My only issue was the music at the pool was obviously loud. We could hardly carry on a conversation it was so loud. I get that it’s a “party” but that was just ridiculous. It literally hurt my ears.

🇺🇸

Deater

8.2

August 2023

The Islander was clean and comfortable. They had coffee in the lobby fresh and good. Staff were super nice and helpful. The location was perfect. We could walk to town and get around easy.

The only reason it didn't get a ten is because on our only full day there the pool and swim up bar was closed. That was pretty disappointing. As that was one of the main reasons I choose this motel.

Points of Interest Around Islander Inn

Attractions

African Safari Wildlife Park

9.2mi

Lake Erie

15.5mi

Pools

Location

  • Outdoor

Availability

  • Seasonal

Location

  • Outdoor

Age restrictions

  • All ages

Availability

  • Seasonal

Amenities of Islander Inn

Outdoor swimming pool

Free wifi

Air conditioning

Bar

Non-smoking rooms

Wheelchair accessible

Beach chairs/Loungers

Elevator

Picnic area

Balcony

Upper floors accessible by elevator

Stay rules - Islander Inn

  • Check-in / Check-out

  • Pets

  • Internet

  • Age restrictions

  • Curfew

  • Parking

  • Children and beds

  • Cards accepted at this property