Ahead of our arrival the team were super accommodating of our late room swap request. On arrival we were very pleased with the room; great size, layout, loved the decor and very pleased to have our own nespresso machine with daily pod top up. Comfortable beds, black out blinds and a fan were boxes ticked for solid nights sleeps. A great breakfast choice overlooking the harbour, and lovely, friendly but not intrusive staff too - a very happy stay !!!

Very good vegetarian breakfast for two,lovely superior room overlooking the sea, very comfortable and cj organised the flowers I arranged from Scilly flowers for the room and red wine plus greeted my sister and brother in law on arrival at the hotel.Excellent location and the staff were friendly , warm and efficient. For a first visit to the Scilly isles this was amazing, weather held good for 4 days in march and they were able to explore st marys by foot, visit tresco and st Agnes by boat, find Sea glass, ancient burial chambers and wells. Etc. Beautiful long weekend and we'll worth the visit. I'm certain the couple will visit again , 10 out of 10 .

The sea view and position of the Inn was superb. The staff were wonderfully friendly, helpful and kind. The dinner in the evenings were delicious. The outside terraces with the fantastic views across the harbour were lovely.

On the whole the breakfasts were excellent but we had one breakfast with scrambled egg which was inedible, dried up scrapings from the bottom of the pan.

Nice hotel, central, stayed there before and it is the same. Nothing wrong with it. One of the few places on the island which will serve you food if you have not booked a table!!! (in the bar). Beds very comfortable.

Unbelievably expensive at £290 for 1 night, but that is Scilly Islands nowadays, with prices gone up 3x since before covid. But of course I knew that when booking it. The shower flow rate was very low, but usable.

The breakfast was fantastic, excellent quality ingredients and all freshly prepared. As good as it gets. The room we stayed in appeared newly renovated. It was immaculate. Useful things like USB charging points by the bed. Good quality toiletries. Also really nice tea, coffee and biscuits. I've saved the best till last and that was the view from the room. See photo. There are a table and easy chairs to allow you to sit and enjoy this. Also the hotel location is absolutely spot on for access to the pier for visiting the other islands by boat. We only stayed for a long weekend but the location allowed us to make the absolute most of our stay.

There is some noise from the pub outdoor terrace below so it could disturb you if you want to go to bed before 11. After 11 the outdoor terrace is closed so it didn't cause a problem for us.

Location central! Staff were very friendly and extremely helpful always smiling.

Personally I found the trek to the room ( top floor of the hotel) difficult due to my health situation. To be fair I had not disclosed this to booking.com or the hotel. When leaving one of the staff helped me with my case. It was at that point I realised how much strength I had lost.

The location is amazing and not far at all from harbour. The staff were amazing, always helpful and polite. Helped with all queries including locating a lost jacket which was on another island and organised for it to be returned at St Mary’s. Definitely going above and beyond. Breakfast is very enjoyable from the service to the view of the harbour and the variety in the menu. The Atlantic is an excellent location and close to shops, cafes, town and the beaches.

If room with harbour view available ask for that.

Location was excellent. Nice clean and fresh hotel. Very well appointed and cared for rooms and restaurant. Outside bar are with view of the bay wonderful. All staff were exceptional. From the check in desk, to breakfast, and everyone else we came across. Made an awesome stay even more fun. Can’t rate it highly enough.

Nothing

Almost everything about it! Friendly, comfy, perfect location, nice food, appropriately quirky decor, animated but chilled hotel bar etc

It was baking hot in our room in October & it didn't need to be. The radiators were off & we opened the windows as much as we could but the heating to the rest of the hotel meant the pipes coming into the room were red hot raising the temperature excessivly & we couldn't turn them off. It was hard to sleep because of it, we had to choose between dessication or the windy & rainy outside coming into the room. So if you like a hot room you'll be fine.

From the superb location, delicious menu, cosy pub and fabulous open views across the harbour to the exceptional staff (Megan and Alex particularly fab!) The Atlantic was perfect… so much so we’ve booked our next trip there already!

Nothing