It was very welcoming when we arrived, although our rooms had a heating problem they got it fixed in the evening while we ate. Menu looked good - Wish we'd been able to eat here but we were meeting colleagues at their accom/pub up the road - which was chilly and empty (only us there) in the bar and the food was more expensive and had less choice. Bed was super comfy - one of the best I've had, shower was good too and plenty of tea/coffee etc Breakfast was good- just good quality food and the right sort of choices, also Excellent freshly brewed coffee. Again would have been exceeds expecations - yog and raspberries blueberries etc - nice OJ, cooked breakfast was huge - I was surprised to see smoked salmon and scrambled eggs (amazing in this price hotel) but the salmon delivery was late, never the less the eggs were good. Staff really lovely - both on arrival and at breakfast

It would have been exceeded expectations for everything - but the cold-weather-gremlins had struck - and inevitably the central heating to the bedrooms was down when we arrived (guessing it was the pump as downstiars was warm) but they had provided fan heater in each room so was manageable - and it was fixed while we were out getting a meal. . The rooms would have felt a bit cramped for suitcases etc if there had been two staying.

Everyone was so accommodating and kind and really, really friendly. Top quality, well kept cask ales. The kitchen were totally flexible to my food intolerances and Amanda even went out of her way to find bread that I can eat. The room was lovely, the en suite was spot on. Even the music in the bar was great. The hotel has parking. Breakfast was wonderful.

Erm...... seriously? Anything I could say would be overly picky. My tv didn't work; someone came and fixed it. There was nothing wrong with the hotel whatsoever. Oh boy the traffic noise at the weekends is mental! But that's just Castleton in July. I wouldn't hesitate to come here again.

This was our second stay here. We came back because we loved it so much. Very cosy pub, amazing location, lovely staff, great all round! We stayed in room 7, which we called the little cave. We had the best nights sleep, amazing room. A little noisy from traffic, just need some earplugs! But we still slept like babies!

My only little issue was the plastic cups in a plastic bag that were laid out for drinking water. Purely from a sustainable viewpoint, it would be great if these could be exchanged for reusable tumblers 😊

The location is ideal: nestled in the heart of the Hope Valley beneath the atmospheric Peveril Castle, the inn is perfectly placed for walks to caverns, hikes up Mam Tor or buses further afield if the weather isn’t being cooperative. It provides front row views of The Garland Day procession too. The room was cosy, comfortable and provided three excellent nights’ sleep. The breakfast included was decent enough and the pub itself offers a good selection of hearty traditional fare and cask ales served by friendly staff.

The food was all exceptional. We dined there twice and enjoyed 3 perfect breakfasts . The dinners were generous and good quality ... home cooked pies and the best sticky toffee pudding I've ever had. Everything was clean. Location perfect for enjoying the many features of Castleton. Staff all friendly, helpful and efficient.

Our room was quite small . However, it was advertised as such in fairness. Lack of plug sockets in bedroom Even a bedside lamp was unusable as it did not have a socket !

The food was amazing. Even the small plates are more than enough. The breakfast was cooked to order and fabulous. The sausage especially was yummy. The bedroom was comfy and more than big enough for a short stay, room five. The staff were very friendly and nothing was too much trouble.

The only thing I would say and it's from a personal perspective, was that the sliding door on the bathroom did not give much privacy. If it doesn't bother you to have a fully closing door, then it will be fine. Lovely touch of the toiletries for use.

Amanda and the staff were all brilliant, from when i first arrived to checking out. The breakfast was top notch as were the bar and evening meals i had there. Good selection of beers and lagers at a price i would expect to pay. I will definatly be staying there again when time allows.

The towel to dry off in the shower was a little small, as i am a little on the large size it was like trying to dry Jumbo the elephant with a postage stamp, but still managed.

The rooms were nice the radiators were set that we could turn them up or down which was good the beds were comfortable the breakfast was nice the location was very good

At breakfast we were offered tea or coffee which I do not drink I asked if I could have a hot chocolate and was told yes I could but I would be charged for it so orange juice was the only thing that I could drink that was included in the price of my breakfast

I stayed one night in a single room. It had ample space and had both a kettle with refreshments and a tv. The room was warm, smelt fresh and the bed was extremely comfortable. I particularly appreciated having lovely fat pillows! I ate in the restaurant in the evening. It was Sunday and there was a choice of roast dinners. I ordered the nutroast and it was lovely, served with al dente veg. I had the apple crumble for dessert which was super and came with a good helping of custard. I love that the meals are home cooked and although the menu says orders may consequently take more time to be served I didn't have to wait long at all. Staff were very friendly, interesting and friendly. The car park opposite made for easy access to my car and the hotel is very well situated in the heart of beautiful Castleton. Thoroughly recommend it!

I had nothing to complain about but, if I was to offer some suggestions, they would be: Mount the tv on a moveable arm to make it easier to look at (e.g. when in bed). Have signage on the low ceiling where the steps go down to the bathroom. Clearly advise potential guests about the stairs both to the rooms and, in my room, to the bathroom, so physically less able guests are aware.

Helpful friendly staff. Free car parking opposite the pub. Breakfast - continental and cooked options all included. Room was clean with ample space. Comfy bed.Hairdryer and various toiletries as well as a kettle coffee tea and biscuits. Busy pub and restaurant. Lovely location for walking and lots of choice of places to eat and drink close by as well

Ground floor room had window onto courtyard and no view but only there to sleep.