The hotel was in a great location, clean and comfortable. However, because of the staff, I will never return to this hotel.

The staff members were not coordinating well with each other. I was charged for an umbrella, with the claim that I had not returned it, which is completely false. Upon my arrival at the front door, I was instructed to return the umbrella. I even emailed them to explain that we returned it every day, but they have not responded to my emails. The staff was indifferent, and I didn’t feel welcomed, possibly because it was the end of the year.

From the moment you step inside, the experience feels magical. I was warmly greeted by the doormen, and the staff was exceptionally friendly. The check-in process was quick and seamless. The room was absolutely stunning—just like the pictures—and I was pleasantly surprised by the well-stocked minibar and in-room snacks. The restaurant and bar were incredibly high-end and classy, with strong, expertly crafted drinks and delicious food. It’s the perfect getaway for a fancy and romantic time with your partner. I will definitely be staying here again!

While I understand that fancy restaurants and bars typically don’t have TVs, as a sports fan, I would have appreciated at least one screen at the bar. It was a Friday night with the Warriors playing and a fight on as well, and it would have been great to catch some of the action while enjoying the excellent atmosphere.

Loved the location, the friendly staff and the comfortable room. Room service were faultless and food was delicious.

I would have liked housekeeping to be more proactive, when we stayed our room was not cleaned at all one day - despite being out for most of the day and the following day they attended to the room at 16:30 - when the nightly charge isn’t a small amount, I would expect rooms to be serviced in the morning. It would also have been nice to have a fluffy dressing down - the one we had was worn and clearly used.

If you're coming to San Francisco for business downtown, forget wherever you've stayed in the past and stay at The Jay! Honestly, it's as if someone manifested my perfect short-stay hotel - and I have to suspect that someone on the design team had the female business traveler in mind - they offered clothes steamers instead of irons (I've never used an iron but steam all my work clothes), had a little ledge in the shower to prop your foot on while you shave your legs, and even sealed the shower in its own ventilation system so the bathroom remained humidity free, allowing me to dry my hair in the bathroom immediately after getting out of the shower. On top of all this, the beds were comfy (offering both a firm and less-firm pillow option), the in-room coffee was some of the best I've had, the soaps smelled amazing, and each floor has a filtered water dispenser so I can stay hydrated with fresh, clean water! The overall aesthetic of the hotel is lovely as well and I enjoyed access to the outdoors on the 3rd floor terrace/restaurant.

The only minor challenge was that reception wasn't on the same floor as the exit, so I had to stop off at reception to check out then wait for the elevator a second time (since I couldn't manage the stairs with heels and my luggage) to get to the exit.

The location was really nice and the view was pretty.

The view of the bay was blocked by other buildings. The ac in the room didn’t go below 65 and couldn’t make it less than 70. Water pressure was really bad and it took forever for hot water

One of the best hotels I’ve ever stayed in. Rooms are super new! Bay view is STUNNING! I’m 100% positive that you can’t find a better view in SF. Really nice area with lots of restaurants. Felt so nice being in this hotel. Will definitely stay there again! Deserves 5* truly!

Nothing - everything was PERFECT!

Fantastic room, generous in size, top quality furnishings and amenities. Definitely worthy of a 5* rating. Good location, with some nice breakfast options in vicinity. Great value for money.

Nothing

The design and layout was exceptional. Every detail was thought about and really displayed a beautiful property.

N/A

The suite was big and spacious and suited my needs. Location is very good - close to pier and walkable to union square. The hotel did provide basic housekeeping services which was good. Will stay again but hopefully there’s more offers for the room!

Tv channels / streaming could be better. Tiny tube of body wash is inadequate considering the number of people in room Sofa bed mattress a bit lumpy

Liked everything. Very comfortable stay. Location great. Room and bed very comfortable, clean. Staff was good. Check-in check out very smooth.

There was in-room coffee maker, which very standard courtesy extended in all the hotels world over. So i ws not sure why was it not there in the room. If they had it removed then i must say it was cheap tactic and if they forgot to place one then it was sloppy ....there is no third possibility.