Staff were excellent with information on what was on in Edinburgh. They were also very attentive to guest requirements

Nothing really

The staff were amazing, particularly Anna who helped us check-in a little early (as we arrived in Edinburgh at silly o'clock on the overnight sleeper and it had started to snow!). We were lucky enough to find a Dinner, Bed & Breakfast package that suited us - food was great too. Excellent location - so handy for a long weekend - Waverly rail station is a short walk away and there's on open-top bus city tour stop almost outside the front door (also recommended, by the way - BrightBus).

Only thing I can think of (and it's a very personal thing) is that the pillows were rather thin and didn't work for me (ended up adding a cushion)!

We had a lovely stay at Malmaison. The staff were very friendly and couldn't do enough for you. Dara welcomed us and was always there for a chat. She remembered our plans and asked after us. She had also decorated our room as we had just got married which was a lovely touch. It was very easy to get to, we drove but once we had parked we walked everywhere in Edinburgh as it's so easy to get around. All the food we ate was delicious (breakfast and dinner), served quickly and again with a smile. We had a lovely time - thank you!

Nothing major but the bathroom only had shampoo, a bottle of conditioner would be good.

Old building on St Andrews Square about 15mins walk from the Royal Mile, castle, etc. Easy walk to St James’ Quarter and Playhouse Theatre. Staff are pleasant, polite and professional, nothing too much trouble. Very clean inside. Rooms are really comfortable and the blackout curtains work a treat! Teas, coffees etc in the room are all of really good quality and the beds are so large and comfortable you simply don’t want to get out of them!!

Drinks in the hotel bar are on the expensive side. 4 drinks cost £63 (inc £7 service charge). Thats 2 x 250ml Pinot Noir and 2 x Double G&T.

The hotel was just wonderful! The perfect location for our Christmas-market-week to Edinburgh! Close to/in the center of town, tram and bus stops at the square! Wonderful staff from reception, to restaurant, to breakfast to bar! We felt most welcome and would most certainly come back when staying in town! Big room, comfortable bed, spacious bathroom and Arran soaps and things... what more could we have wanted!

No negative point, just a suggestion: some cheeses and cold cuts at the breakfast buffet would be something we would appreciate.

Loved the location of this hotel, very central and close to waverley train station. Also being dog friendly was amazing. The dog is £25 to stay but you get a little doggy bag, with a ball and treats and a deodorising spray. We were also given a bed with a mat with water and food bowls. Being close to St Andrew's Square was good to take the dog for a walk, although, if your dog likes grass, the park is closed though from 8pm until 7am. So you may have to walk a little further to find a stretch of grass between these times. Yes our dog likes grass! The hotel is very close to Rose Street which boasts a lot of dog friendly pubs, Abbotsford, Robertsons, and Black Rose (after kitchen is closed though). Other dog pubs, Black Bull and Guilford Arms. The hotel room was very spacious and clean. Was extremely comfortable beds and it must be triple glazing as it was quiet given we were next to a busy road. The lounge area was very inviting and you could sit there with the dog, we enjoyed a coffee there.

Being a dog friendly hotel was slighty annoying we couldn't use the hotel bar or go to the grill. We have stayed in other dog friendly hotels where access is unlimited, and your dog can go literally everywhere where you can. Room Service is not 24hrs. I called reception at midnight and the outcome was the result (we did get the bottle of wine), but I was told what was not offered, I.e. the kitchen was closed, the bar was closed and there was a vending machine for beer. To be fair, when I said what is was I wanted we did receive it in the roundabout way.

colours/ decor etc I hate white & Mal Maison is def. not white

At breakfast I asked waiter to ask a customer to turn down his phone. That waiter walked straight passed annoying customer. Other customers were also looking at annoying one. A lady waitress came up to me said, she could not ask this customer to quiet his phone as he was a customer also. Get what I mean? So an annoying customer whom others were distracted by has more importance to the hotel than the respectful ones. ?? If I use your hotel again I will not eat in your restaurant.

Lovely hotel, modern, interesting artwork pieces. Seems they have taken everything into account for the guests convenience. Comfortable big bed, the room was well equipped with everything including ironing board and iron. Centrally located. Great breakfast and well prepared meals. The staff are friendly and very helpful, gave useful tips to us on additional places to see in Edinburgh.

Our bathroom window was directly looking out to another building. We had to remember to pull down blinds. Nothing can be done it was just the location of the room.

Tastefully furnished, modern hotel, very friendly and helpful staff, nice large room with comfortable beds and all the necessary facilities. Cool bar and good restaurant. Nice location on St Andrew Square, from where you can quickly reach Princes St and the old town. The tram station with connections to the airport is only a few metres away.

We had a room at street level and therefore unfortunately no view. However, the windows are well insulated so you couldn't hear a thing. The air conditioning above the beds was a bit annoying, but you can switch it off.

Fantastic stay. Professional staff in all areas . Loved the decor and lighting. The upgrade was a nice gesture to celebrate my 65th birthday🎂. The idea of helping the housekeeping team and environment by not requiring them next morning, but replenish items available on request at reception was original and very smart. . Especially when a drinks voucher is given in a gesture of appreciation . The bar was very busy, and the barman was fantastic on the way he handled the pressure on the Easter Monday evening Reception staff full marks for welcome and advice. ,Catering staff very helpful and profession. I was impressed with the whole Malmaison experience. Location exceptional to city centre and other areas of the city that i wanted to see. I would recommend and stay again both at this hotel and visit the Malmaison Hotel brand in other locations

Weakness was the selection of menu in the restaurant for me. Nothing wrong with the food or service. I experience eating difficulties post cancer treatment. Breakfast selection was amazing . Fantastic experience.